Curious Nashville: A Tombstone Mystery About Who 'Turned From Bloodkin' | Nashville Public Radio

Curious Nashville: A Tombstone Mystery About Who 'Turned From Bloodkin'

Feb 26, 2016

The winning question in our very first Curious Nashville voting round led us on a circuitous path — but we are pleased to say that we found the answer.

WPLN listener Rachael Edge asked the question: 

In the Nashville City Cemetery, there's a grave that says "Margaret H. McCutchen — She Turned From Bloodkin." What's the story behind that?

Listen to the full story above, and then follow along with the visual guide below.

I. The Obituary

A closeup of Margaret McCutchen's obituary in the Tennessean on Dec. 8, 1980
Credit Emily Siner / WPLN

I visited program specialist (and microfilm enthusiast) Sara Brindley at the Nashville Public Library, who tracks down Margaret McCutchen's obituary in the Tennessean on Dec. 8, 1980. Unfortunately, it's rather short on details.

Also in the Tennessean that day: the second of a nine-part undercover exposé on the KKK by reporter Jerry Thompson. That series was later turned into a book.

II. Bloodkin, The Band

As I explored the word "Bloodkin," my boss's boss came across a Southern Gothic rock band of the same name. Bloodkin, the band, was described by Paste Magazine as "the greatest rock 'n' roll band of the last two decades," so that's a pretty high compliment. I especially love "Ghost Runner." It's a fitting song to accompany a story about a cemetery. 

III. The Cemetery

Margaret McCutchen's grave in the Nashville City Cemetery, buried near her family

Margaret is buried in Section 4, Lot 17, between Martha Clenny and Thomas McCutchen. The Nashville City Cemetery is the oldest public cemetery in the county, meaning there were no restrictions as to who could get buried there.

Historic Commission preservationist Fred Zahn, who gave me a tour, tells me this somewhat frightening fact: Nearly 20,000 people are buried in the Nashville City Cemetery, but there are only about 3,000 grave markers. "We haven't bumped into anybody yet," he reassures me.

IV. The Dusty Records

Fred Zahn points to the funeral home listed in one of the cemetery's ledger books, in which Margaret McCutchen is the first entry.
Credit Emily Siner / WPLN

To track down more information about Margaret, Fred Zahn looked in a cemetery ledger book and found the name of the funeral home that buried her. Unfortunately, the owner of the funeral home has since died, too. "So that was a dead end," Fred says.

No pun intended, I snicker. 

"Yeah, cemetery work is full of a lot of puns," he says.

V. The Family Tree

Fred's makeshift family tree of the McCutchen/Wadley family
Credit Emily Siner / WPLN

Finally, Fred finds an email about a nearby grave from Taylor Wadley — Margaret's great-nephew, as he shows me on this family tree. Fred sends Taylor a message on Facebook, and Taylor tells him the story of Margaret's epitaph as he knows it. Later, we check in with another side of the family, who has a different version of the story.

Submit your own question at curious.wpln.org